Why We Still Hate Hr

In: Business and Management

Submitted By Jason117
Words 538
Pages 3
Why We Still Hate HR
By Karen Southall Watts (2008)
A few years ago, while plowing through my reading and research in graduate school I read an article called "Why we hate HR" by Keith H. Hammonds. In his extensive look at HR, mostly from a big corporation viewpoint, he described HR as "a dark bureaucratic force that blindly enforces nonsensical rules, resists creativity, and impedes constructive change." Ouch! From my point of view, training entrepreneurs, coaching businesswomen and talking to jobseekers I must say, we still hate HR. Let me tell you why. The folks in HR still don't get it. As a group they still don't understand what the company does, who the customers are and what the core business drivers are. I base this assessment on the calls I get from clients that start with the words, "You'll never believe what HR did this time." The HR professionals I've talked to over the last few years have a mind-boggling understanding of paperwork, regulations and dodging phone calls. However, once they glance outside their own office they seem to be mystified. There is still a bias towards "efficiency" instead of value. HR offices are keyed into the number of hours of training they provide-not the results delivered. They seem to collect job applications and process job candidates in a manner designed to prove their own competency and not as a pipeline for needed talent. Automated systems may make it easier to outsource the administrative tasks of HR, but they don't necessarily add value. Most importantly, HR still doesn't work for you. As a profession HR still abhors exceptions, flexibility and individuality. Perhaps it's the constant fear of legal action or maybe it's just too much work. Whatever the reason, HR does not work for job candidates or current employees and most unfortunately they don't really work well for the companies paying their salaries. The two most…...

Similar Documents

Why We Hate Hr?

...A REVIEW OF “WHY WE HATE HUMAN REOURCE Name: Instructor: Course: Date: A review of “Why we hate HR” HR stands for human resources. HR refers to a company element, which deals with the aspects/needs of humans among the workers (Fisher et al, 2008). In many companies, an HR department can provide a variety of services for employees. Some employees working in HR are taken as forming the department, but many workers outside the department can do something not only on financial matters, but also on the human aspects of workers employment. For instance, a supervisor may have a responsibility to hire and fir e workers, giving day-to-day feedback on work, writing employee reviews and supporting and encouraging workers. This is so even though a supervisor is not one of the HR departments. In many large companies and some small ones, there have been critiques that there is a lack of humanity in terms of caring for the employees. When we examine in the full spectrum of their functions within the company, Human Resources is extremely valuable to a company. The article by Keith H. Hammonds gives the flaws in human resources. Reading it one may seem to have a notion that the writer is against HR in business organizations, which is not the case. Hammonds identifies the flaws in HR, and his criticism gives some hints to improving HR so that it can produce desirable results in business. The writer identifies some of the flaws and argues around them in...

Words: 1609 - Pages: 7

Hate Crimes and Why They Happen

...Hate Crimes and Why They Happen Allison M Thompson Hate Crimes and Why They Happen The Matthew Sheppard Law also known as Hate Crime legislation was created by the powers that be in an effort to deter criminals from committing hate crimes. This legislation was voted into law in April 2009 in a vote of 246 to 175; its purpose was to prevent crimes that were being committed against people because of their race, color, or national origin. Such criminal activity is motivated by bias that is different from other criminal acts. These criminal acts include crimes against gays, crimes against blacks and also crimes against Hispanic’s. All of this crime is committed in ways that are different from other types of assaults. One such example would be the crime of Beaner Hopping; this is a crime against Hispanic’s, where bored young white male will go out in search of young Hispanic male to harass. Such crimes as beaner hopping are committed to send message to their victim. In a hate crime the victim is rarely robbed and in most cases racist’s symbols are used. These crime are very personal in nature, the burning of a cross on the front lawn of a black family or the swastika that is painted on a synagogue are not only personal crimes but also harmful in nature. It has been said that because the First Amendment gives every American the right to speak freely it doesn’t give any American to right to hurt another human because he doesn’t care for his or her natural origin. The......

Words: 1042 - Pages: 5

Why We Hate Hr

...SUMMARY In the knowledge economy, companies with the best talent win. And finding, nurturing, and developing that talent should be one of the most important tasks in a corporation. So why does human resources do such a bad job – and how can we fix it? Keith Hammonds, the deputy editor of Fast Company, asserts that human resources offices should manage an organization’s human resources the same way the information technology office manages its computers and the finance office manages its capital. They should think strategically. Instead, human resources offices focus on such administrivia as pay, benefits, and retirement - - processes increasingly being outsourced. That should be good news: human resources offices will then be free to focus on the strategic implications of what they do - - are their actions serving the organization’s strategic goals and making it more effective and successful? Unfortunately, they’re not used to thinking about such things and aren’t very good at it. Hammonds identifies four reasons why human resources offices aren’t doing a good job and suggests five ways to fix them. CRITIQUE In a well written article, Hammond delivers what he promises. His characterization of the kinds of people who generally seek to work in human resources is accurate. They like to work with people, but aren’t very business oriented. Their perspective is typically much like that of a social worker. Human resources offices emphasize inputs......

Words: 545 - Pages: 3

Why Didn't We Know

...Why Didn’t We Know? Table of Contents Problem Identification ……………………………………………………………….…… 3 Ineffective Communication Ineffective Listening Abilities Ineffective Development of project team Situation Analysis …………………………………………………………………….…… 4 Ineffective Communication Ineffective Listening Abilities Ineffective Development of project team Recommendations ………………………………………………………………………..... 6 Ineffective Communication Ineffective Listening Abilities Ineffective Development of project team References ……………………………………………………………………………..…... 8 Problem Identification In the Harvard Business Review Case Study, “Why Didn’t We Know?” Ralph Hasson describes circumstances where communication, listening, and the development of a sales team could have greatly circumvented a lawsuit against the Galvatrens Company. Three of the problem areas that affect this case are, ineffective communication skills, ineffective listening abilities, and the ineffective development of the sales team. Ineffective Communication Engleberg & Wynn identifies communication as an instrument used by members of a group to share information and opinions, make decisions, solve problems, and develop interpersonal relationships. (Engleberg & Wynn, 2013, p. 5). The managers and employees of Galvatrens lack these communication skills and have caused major issues throughout the organization. In this article, it shows Galvatrens lacking in......

Words: 1494 - Pages: 6

Why We Forget

...One may remember the score to last year’s basketball game but forget a mother’s birthday. Remember faces, but not names. To be presented with so many pieces of information daily, the struggle to retain information plagues everyone. Why do we forget information that we try so hard to remember? Thorough case studies have been performed and a few prevailing theories about why this is and ways to reduce habits of forgetting have emerged. Memory is attributed to the functioning of three stages: encoding – the process of storing data, storage – the process of retaining data, and retrieval - the process of recovering data. Several factors are tied together and influence forgetting. It can happen before or even after the actual memory process. Keywords: memory process, encoding, storage, retrieval Why We Forget Forgetting is the loss of information stored in an individual’s memory. It’s the process in which older memories cannot be recalled from ones memory databank. Research studied by Edward Thorndike which was compiled in his novel “The Psychology of Learning” in 1914 shows one possible explanation: “The Decay Theory of Forgetting” found that there is a theory to explain this behavior. Over time, if the specific memory isn’t recalled and an effort isn’t made to preserve the notion or event, it will fade with time. If an attempt of recalling a memory is not made within a certain timeframe the memory will fade to darkness. Another theory known as “Interference Theory” was......

Words: 2191 - Pages: 9

Why We Buy

...Marketing 310 Why We Buy: The Science of Shopping I chose the book Why We Buy: The Science of Shopping by Paco Underhill. This book really opened my eyes to a lot of marketing issues. In all honesty, I chose this book because I’ve always found the idea behind shopping interesting and I’ve always wondered why I walk out of the store with an item I don’t even need. After reading the book, I discovered that this book is actually not about that at all. This book is actually far more interesting and tackles some serious problems in marketing today. These days, very few stores open to serve new markets. The primary purpose of a store in this day and age is to steal someone else’s market share. The book outlines key elements that are mandatory for success in marketing. The book starts with how retail outlets need to monitor the paths that people take in the store. How people enter and move around the store, and which direction they take. By observing how customers move around, we can gear end caps and aisles accordingly to push out the products we need to sell the most. The trick is to walk the store in a customer’s shoes. It’s been proven that people tend to enter a store and take the direction they typically drive on. It’s extremely important to understand this concept when planning out displays. It’s very important for people to find what they’re looking for immediately. Customers don’t want to have to search high and low to find the product they need. A......

Words: 3384 - Pages: 14

Why We Hate Hr

...one which is most criticised. The debate whether HR is for the benefit of the employees or the organization has been one of the most contentious issues in management. The fact is that, the purpose of HR function is to enable the organization to achieve its strategic goals by providing it with the best possible talent. Therefore, before evaluating whether HR is on the side of employee or management, one must understand that HR is part of the organization and exists for the benefit of the organization. However, this does not necessarily mean that HR has to be against the interest of employees. The HR is the function which is responsible for managing the organization’s human capital. In this age of Knowledge economy, human capital is a strategic asset which can give the organization a competitive advantage. However, since HR is the employee facing function, employees expect HR to be of assistance to them and help them with their issues at the workplace. When this does not happen due to one reason or another, the HR is seen as the Bad party which is just working against employee interest. In reality, the fact is that the HR is neither on the side of the management, nor on the side of the employee. The purpose of HR is to meet its role in the organizational strategy. When we talk of strategy, many a times, HR gets ignored because of a feeling that HR cannot be responsible for anything strategic. The most well known function of HR such as recruitment, compensation, training......

Words: 1695 - Pages: 7

Why Didn't We Know?

...A whistle-blower’s lawsuit alerts Galvatrens to deep flaws in its system for uncovering misconduct. How should management and the board respond? HBR CASE STUDY Why Didn’t We Know? by Ralph Hasson COPYRIGHT © 2007 HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL PUBLISHING CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. It was 9:30 in the evening of what had been a very long Friday when the phone rang in Chip Brownlee’s home study. On the line was Arch Carter, the lead director of Galvatrens, the Houston-based consumer products company that Chip had led as chairman and CEO for the past ten years. “I just got your voice mail,” Arch said. “The parts about a lawsuit and accusations that we manipulated our sales numbers certainly got my attention. What’s going on?” “At this point, I don’t know much,” Chip responded, “but I wanted to give you a heads-up. A former divisional sales manager has filed a lawsuit against the company, charging he was wrongfully terminated because he tried to report an illegal scheme to inflate sales.” Chip had received a copy of the lawsuit that afternoon. As he’d read through the complaint, he’d gotten a whole new perspective on the multiple departures that had rocked Sales dur- ing the past four weeks. The plaintiff was Mike Fields, who had left Galvatrens three weeks earlier. He claimed that he’d come across a plan devised by Greg Wilson, another divisional sales manager. According to Mike, Greg had proposed shipping goods to a few of his bigger customers, billing them, and booking the......

Words: 3262 - Pages: 14

Why We Buy

...Page 1 Martin Lindstrom’s Buy•ology and Paco Underhill’s Why we Buy should be required reading for all business related major students. In Paco Underhill’s book he really digs in to and investigates that will make a person purchase on product from another. Paco Underhill is like the frontline specialist. On the sales floor is where he rules changing and adapting to consumers needs and wants. He is able to tell you why a product in one store is selling but not in another. Or why products that have huge advertisement budget have not really left the shelf. Now where Underhill is on the sales floor in his book, Martin Lindstrom digs into the minds of the consumers in his book Buy•ology. By doing this Lindstrom is able to identify why we purchase the products/ services we do. Now one thing that I really learned in Lindstrom’s book is that we lie. Consumers lie time and time again, not only are we lying to each other or surveys but to are selfs. Either that or we are to scared to tell the truth to anyone. In one of Lindstrom’s studies he was testing a new show for a U.S. audience that was already doing great in the U.K. The show was called Quizmania, to see how the audience was going to react to this show before it was even aired Lindstrom arranged at test of two hundred people. They had three shows for the group of two hundred to watch Quizmania, The Swan, and How Clean Is Your House? Now going into this study Lindstrom already new what people thought of both How......

Words: 4277 - Pages: 18

Why We Broke Up

... Begin Reading Table of Contents Copyright Page For Charlotte—why we got together —D.H. + M.K. In a sec you’ll hear a thunk. At your front door, the one nobody uses. It’ll rattle the hinges a bit when it lands, because it’s so weighty and important, a little jangle along with the thunk, and Joan will look up from whatever she’s cooking. She will look down in her saucepan, worried that if she goes to see what it is it’ll boil over. I can see her frown in the reflection of the bubbly sauce or whatnot. But she’ll go, she’ll go and see. You won’t, Ed. You wouldn’t. You’re upstairs probably, sweaty and alone. You should be taking a shower, but you’re heartbroken on the bed, I hope, so it’s your sister, Joan, who will open the door even though the thunk’s for you. You won’t even know or hear what’s being dumped at your door. You won’t even know why it even happened. It’s a beautiful day, sunny and whatnot. The sort of day when you think everything will be all right, etc. Not the right day for this, not for us, who went out when it rains, from October 5 until November 12. But it’s December now, and the sky is bright, and it’s clear to me. I’m telling you why we broke up, Ed. I’m writing it in this letter, the whole truth of why it happened. And the truth is that I goddamn loved you so much. The thunk is the box, Ed. This is what I am leaving you. I found it down in the basement, just grabbed the box when all of our things were too much for my bed stand drawer. Plus I......

Words: 57192 - Pages: 229

Why Didn't We Know

...Case #1 – Team ACT Contributors: Leroy: ineffective development of an effective project team ASSIGNMENT:  Case Analysis – Why didn’t we know, by Ralph Hasson.   DESCRIPTION:  This case study will provide an analysis of the problems and the mechanisms leading up to the accusations against Galvatrens.  Galvatrens is a US based consumer products company.  The company discovers a significant problem within their sales department via a whistleblower that has been fired.  Through this study we will examine the communication breakdown and identify key instances of failure.   Problem Identified -A project team should include managers and team members with interpersonal skills, training and team building to enhance the team’s performance throughout the project (PMI, 2008, p. 232). The sales team for Galvatrens was not successfully developed. There were several flaws in the initial structure of the sales team, the management plan and execution, which led to inefficient management. Situation Analysis -The chain of command within Galvatrens directly affects the development of the sales team. The hierarchy of management has the COO responsible for daily operations, including the sales team, which is not consistent throughout all operations (Hasson, 2007). The next dilemma is with the CEO, Chip Brownlee. He follows the ill advice of the senior vice president of HR, Dale Willis. Dale believes that if something is outside the management’s chains of command it can allow a problem......

Words: 667 - Pages: 3

Why We Hate Hr?

...Why We Hate HR In a knowledge economy, companies with the best talent win. And finding, nurturing, and developing that talent should be one of the most important tasks in a corporation. So why does human resources do such a bad job From: Issue 97 | August 2005 | Page 40 | By: Keith H. Hammonds Well, here's a rockin' party: a gathering of several hundred midlevel human (Yo, Wayne Newton! How's the 401(k)?) They are here, ensconced for two days at faux to confer on "strategic HR leadership," a conceit that sounds, to the lay observer, at once frightening and self contradictory. If not plain laughable. Because let's face it: After close to 20 years of hopeful rhetoric about becoming "strategic partners" with a "seat at the table" where the business decisions that matter are made, most human aren't nearly there. They have no seat, and the table is locked inside a conference room to which they have no key. HR people are, for most practical purposes, neither strategic nor leaders. I don't care for Las Vegas. And if it's not clear already, I don't like HR, either, which is why I'm here. The human force that blindly enforces nonsensical rules, resists creativity, and impedes constructive change. HR is the corporate function with the greatest potential the one that most consistently underdelivers. And I am here to find out why. Why are annual performance appraisals so time henchman for the chief financial officer,......

Words: 3530 - Pages: 15

Why Do We Still Read Jane Austen Today?

...Why do we still read Austen today? By Ida Palmer Jane Austen is considered a revolutionary novelist and prose-writer, arguably rivalled only by the likes of William Shakespeare or Oscar Wilde. But, 200 years after her books were written, why do we still read them today? Possibly the most apparent reason is Austen’s ability to make us feel better about ourselves. Her books are awash with moral guidance as we see the main characters go on journeys and encounter obstacles in their quest for happiness, and we cannot help but put ourselves in their shoes and wonder “What would I do?”. Austen uses subtlety to guide us through moral difficulties, avoiding the preachy tone of “You SHOULD do this”, and instead incorporating the delicate air of “This is a possibility.” Our need for guidance and role models relates back to the inescapable human desire for valid instruction from an influential leader; In her time, when unmarried women were virtually invisible on the social scale, Austen was not a typical body for a role model, and so many of her readers would not have uncovered, or expected, the moral messages written into her storylines. Contemporary readers, however, can easily unpick the subtleties in Austen’s work and indentify the intricacy in her “comedy of manners”. Another perfectly valid reason we still read Austen today is simply because she is an eloquent and articulate writer. She writes with wit, flair, irony, and an unmatchable humour in her tone. Her novels,......

Words: 527 - Pages: 3

Why Do We Sleep

...Comp 1 Why do we sleep? Why do we sleep, how is it necessary? It is well known that you have to sleep. If you do not sleep you will die in a week or so. With that being said what does sleep do? We know it makes you feel alert and energized. Is it just evolution at work to keep us out of harm’s way at night? Is sleep our body’s way of conserving energy? Is it a way for our brains to imprint memories, and be creative? Does it clean our brain out? Do we actually need eight hours of sleep? Or is it a mix of a few reasons? Sleep is defiantly an important function in our bodies or we would not get so tired at night we just can’t stay awake. Our brains have a region devoted to letting us know when to sleep it is our biological clock. It knows when we should be awake and when we should sleep and you cannot change it knows that when the sun comes up its time to be awake and a few hours after dark it is time to sleep. But what does sleep do other than have you lay still and have dreams? Is evolution the reason? Are we safer by not hurting ourselves at night or worse getting preyed upon? That fact is debatable. By not moving around you won’t hurt yourself. And the predators will not find you as easily. But there are other things to worry about. What about natural disasters like fires, floods, tornados, and earth quakes? I would think being conscious would be more helpful with these situations even if you are not moving around. So I think we can rule out the evolutionary......

Words: 831 - Pages: 4

Why We Hate Hr

...The article Why We Hate HR by Keith Hammonds, deputy editor for Fast Company, discusses the ineffectiveness human resources have on a company. He very boldly argues that HRM’s striving to become involved in strategic business planning and to have “a seat at the table” are inhibited by the routine functions of HR and administrative expectations (Hammonds, 2005, p. 1). Hammonds’ article develops claims that lead up to his conclusion that HR is a wasted talent for a company to utilize to gain differentiation, competiveness, and value. The critiques Hammonds used to define human resources can be used to explore the potential value and capabilities HR has to offer a business and possibilities of a company gaining in the HR area of the work force. Hammonds argues that the focus on performance impedes on an organization’s ability to deliver value to employees and customers. “You’re only effective if you add value,” he quotes Dave Ulrich, “… you’re not measured by what you do but by what you deliver,” (Hammonds, p. 3). In order to achieve added value, organizations can consider adopting new HR practices. In R. Wayne Mondy’s Human Resource Management text book, the evolution of HR is discussed with a simple conclusion that there is no pattern for how human resource tasks are now achieved. The only certainty is that the previously identified HR functions must still be accomplished. Each company must choose the appropriate vehicle for doing these tasks based on specific needs...

Words: 683 - Pages: 3

Laura Harrier | saison 2, épisode 7 | nemetschek