Southwest Winglets Case

In: Other Topics

Submitted By leason
Words 874
Pages 4
MEMO TO: Scott Topping, Director of Finance
DATE: March 31, 2009
SUBJECT: Blended Winglet Project
In order to calculate Southwest’s expected future cash flows from the Blended Winglet project we made specific decisions in setting the cash flows. First, we assumed that the cost of a Winglet is $700,000 per pair. Additionally, we assumed initial costs of: installation downtown per plane of $5,000, an installation cost of $56,000, and a facility modification cost of $1,200. Since costs were expected to rise 3% over the extended life of the project, we calculated this 3% inflation rate into restricted runways savings, which in year one started at $500, and we calculated the 3% inflation rate into maintenance costs, which in year one were estimated at $2,100. Since the rise in costs of 3% applied to all costs except fuel, we assumed over the life of the project that fuel savings from incorporating the winglets was $142,800 each year.
The deprecation over the life of the winglets was determined using the 7-year MACRS method. However, the Job Creation and Worker Assistance Act of 2002 allowed for an additional 50% of the project to be depreciated in the first year. The depreciation schedule used for the Winglets project is illustrated in Appendix 1. With a marginal tax rate of 39%, the final net income over the life of the project is also given in Appendix 1. The expected future net cash flows were then found from summing the above costs and savings and adding back in depreciation for that year. Finally, in year 20, the expected net salvage value at the end of the project was added back into the expected future cash flow for year 20. Using these project implementation costs, the expected return, or internal rate of return, on the Winglets project, is 15%.
Several assumptions were made to calculate the weighted average cost of capital. According to Note 9…...

Similar Documents

Southwest Airlines Case Analysis

...4315*2 Team 4 Strategic Profile and Case Analysis Purpose In the airline industry competitors have to work hard to maintain market share and even more to increase their share. Southwest Airlines has become the market share leader in terms of passengers carried with the simple strategy: “low-cost/low-price/no-frills.” They have done an excellent job in implementing and executing their strategy elements. Some of the most crucial executions in the Southwest strategy are their point-to-point scheduling of flights, customer service and customer satisfaction, and appreciation of employee involvement for continuous company improvement. Although many other airlines can implement the same strategic elements as Southwest has, they would still be behind the times since Southwest has been working efficiently from inception. Throughout this analysis of their performance, one may conform his or her own opinion on how to grade Southwest with the information provided. Alternative strategic suggestions will be evaluated with a preferred alternative choice that could improve the Southwest image and performance. Situation Analysis General Environmental Analysis Until the Airline Deregulation Act of 1978, the government had control over airline fares, routes, and market entry. But since Southwest's initial plan was to fly only intrastate routes, they did not have to come under the regulation of the Civil Aeronautics Board. Southwest did, however, encounter some legal......

Words: 2295 - Pages: 10

Southwest Case

... passengers)       Transferring   TURNAROUND   PROCESS     INBOUND   FLIGHT   Passengers   Con;nuing   Transferring   Cargo   Con;nuing   Maintenance     Price   FUEL   Con;nuing  flight   Connec;ng  flight     Quan;ty  related  to  ;me  allowance     OTIS   Informa;on     FINAL  TRIM   Actual  number  of  passengers     Actual  amount  of  cargo  and   fuel   •  BoSle  neck  à  Delayed  transfers  (15min  instead  of  usual  20  -­‐  30   minutes)  (in  case  of  FLIGHT  110  it  lasts  17minutes)   •  In  general  à  good  training,  organiza;on  and  coopera;on  within   the  SOUTHWEST  airlines   •  Bal;more  airport  was  one  of  the  very  busy  ones,  with  high   u;liza;on  rate  (high  number  of  flight  on  limited  number  of  gates)   and  low  number  of  available  workers   •  Tight  labor  market  à  lack  of  people  à  need  for  longer  hours  in   order  to  make  opera;ons  work   •  Long  working  hours  were  solved  by  shortening  training  ;me  à  Less   trained  personnel     •  BOTTLE  NECK     • ......

Words: 395 - Pages: 2

Southwest Case Study

...Strategic Management Case Analysis: Southwest Airlines Southwest Airlines Co. (Southwest) is often cited as a success story in terms of strategic management. Southwest is a passenger airline that provides scheduled air transportation in the United States. Primarily, the company offers passengers low-fare, point-to-point air transport services in 72 cities in 37 states all throughout America (MarketLine, 2012). Southwest is headquartered in Dallas, Texas, and has about 45,392 employees as of FY2011. For FY2011, the company generated revenues of $15.658 billion, increasing by 29.4% over FY2010 (MarketLine, 2012). Southwest reported net profit of $178 million in FY2011. It must be noted that the airline industry is famed for its cut-throat competitiveness. However, since its inception in 1971, Southwest has been able to steadily rise to the top of airline rankings due to its Low Cost Leadership strategy (Muduli & Kaura, 2011); Box & Byus, 2009). Southwest also consistently offers on-time arrival that, combined with low-priced fares, makes it highly favorable for passengers. Southwest is able to achieve its strategy by using a linear, point-to-point network and does not have an airport hub (Tierney & Kuby, 2008). As a result, the company’s aircraft are seldom idle while its competitors spend prolonged idle time while passengers switch planes at the hub (Tierney & Kuby, 2008). Because of the impact of this strategy on passengers and the industry as a whole, competitors tend to...

Words: 811 - Pages: 4

Southwest Airlines Case Study

...Southwest Airlines Case Study After the acquisition of AirTran, Southwest Airlines (SWA), a company with years of profitability in airline industry is now facing challenges in both external and internal environment. The strength of success in marketing strategy and organizational management and the threats from uncertainty environment exist at the same time. This paper is a brief analysis of the company’s strategy and estimated future performance. External Environment Airlines in United States present a wide variety of services based on their strategies to satisfy different needs of the leisure travelers group and business travelers group. There are three main groups of airlines, which are national airlines, regional airlines and commuter or feeder carriers. Based on the territories they serve, airlines differ in routes. The two major types are point-to-point and hub-and-spoke. Both strategies have their own inherent costs and organizational implications. An airline can provide plenty of services: while most airlines have two classes of service, there are also airlines providing services in different selected classes. After the complete removal of government controls, airlines industry is going on a shakeout under the severe competition which is expected to last a long period. The industry is so difficult that its suppliers have high bargaining power; business requires large expenditures; and the price wars are extreme intensive. To survive and compete in this......

Words: 2339 - Pages: 10


...Southwest “Winglets” Case Expected Future Cash Flow of Blended Winglet Project The cash flow estimations for this project were based on assumptions gleaned from our engineering department, flight operations department, and facilities department. From our initial investment data, we assumed a winglet cost of $700,000 per aircraft, installation of $56,000 per aircraft, and an additional day of downtime for each aircraft at $5,000 per day. The total value of the winglet installation per aircraft was $761,000 which was depreciated over a 7-year modified MARCS depreciation schedule. In addition to winglet installation, facility upgrade charges were deemed necessary by our Facilities Director. The final estimate for facilities modification was $1200 per aircraft. Installation of the winglets does not increase regular maintenance costs; however, the winglets do increase the possibility of incidental damages. The maintenance department estimated that these damages would cost $210,000 per plane, and that 1% of planes per year would require these repairs. On average, this translates to $2100 per aircraft. Blended Winglet Project Expected Rate of Return Our calculations indicate that the IRR for this project, for any of our anticipated fuel costs, will be significantly higher than the long-term WACC of 11.291% (see part 3, below). However, this calculation could be inaccurate due to the long-term nature of the project and the assumptions inherent in the IRR. The IRR......

Words: 917 - Pages: 4

Southwest Airlines Case Study

...MBA 610 Case Study: Southwest Airlines Corporation 1. Southwest Airlines Corporation is an extremely popular and profitable company due to their strategy of being the nations’ low-fare, high customer satisfaction airline. Southwest is able to offer the nation’s lowest fares due in part to their low operating-cost structure, the lowest in the domestic airline industry. This low operating-cost structure (refer to Exhibit 1 for 5 year financial highlights and 2004 data) is the basis on which Southwest builds its competitive advantage, as it allows Southwest to sell low fare tickets while still enjoying a gross margin percentage of sales (29.2% of sales in 2004) much higher than United Airlines (22.7% of sales), American Airlines (1.9% of sales), and Delta Airlines (18.9% of sales). Southwest achieved this low cost operating structure through eschewing the traditional “hub-and-spoke” approach used by their competitors, and instead flying short haul, medium haul, and point-to-point flights, allowing for more frequent flights. As a result, about 80% of Southwest’s passengers fly non-stop and the overall passenger length is approximately 758 miles. Additionally, Southwest consistently seeks out ways to improve its efficiencies and low cost structure. For an example, at Southwest, turnaround time (from the time a plane lands until it is ready for takeoff) takes approximately 20-25 minutes and requires a ground crew of four plus two people at the gate. By comparison, turnaround......

Words: 805 - Pages: 4

Southwest Case Analysis

...QUESTION 1: What is the strategy of Southwest Airlines? Southwest’s strategy has two overarching themes: 1) Operate as a leading low-fare carrier, and 2) their mantra, “Happy employees make for happy customers.” There are several components to each, which are described in detail below. 1) OPERATING AS A LEADING LOW-FARE CARRIER There are several factors to this strategy: Low fares: SWA had the lowest fares in the industry and endeavored to keep it that way. Low costs: Southwest had the ability to charge low fares in part due to low overhead. Lost cost measures included the following: * Identical fleet of airplanes: This minimized the number of parts required for upkeep and maintenance, and it reduced carrying costs. It allowed SWA to simplify and harmonize training and operating procedures. Finally, not only was inventory “interchangeable” across the organization, staff could have moved freely from one location to the next with little to no training time required. * No meals on flights: A savings of $40 per passenger. * No seat assignments: No staff resources were required to maintain or change seat assignments, and no electronic system capacity was required to track/record such transactions. Simplified approach: Southwest kept the fare structure simple. * Only two types of fares: Regular and off-peak fares (no business class, first class.) * Consistent “within state” fares: For instance, a passenger can fly anywhere......

Words: 760 - Pages: 4

Southwest Case Study

...the analyst must decide which Benchmark to use. In JetBlue’s case it seems that including all airlines will be inappropriate as not all airlines share JetBlue’s low cost strategy. On the other hand, using market leader SouthWest might be too optimistic as southwest was larger than all other US airlines combined and it is doubtful that JetBlue can challenge its position soon. Hence, a possible benchmark may be using low cost airlines in America or globally. Table 3 outlines some of the valuation using different benchmark and different (trailing) ratios. It is clear that benchmark decision is extremely important as different benchmark produce a vastly different picture. For PE Multiples, JetBlue is valued at around $5 if all airline companies are used as a benchmark while it is valued at around 30 dollars if SouthWest is the benchmark. | PE Multiple (Diluted EPS) | PE Multiple (Proforma Basic EPS) | Total Capital Multiple | EBIT Multiple | All Airline companies | $4.92 | $5.61 | $18.75 | $ (9.19) | All low cost airlines | $14.11 | $16.10 | $28.25 | $ (12.55) | All low cost airlines in America | $6.74 | $7.68 | $18.41 | $ (13.14) | All low cost airlines (excluding negative EPS ) | $33.19 | $37.85 | $44.55 | $ (10.93) | All low cost airlines in America (excluding negative EPS ) | $23.27 | $26.54 | $34.35 | $ (11.23) | Market leader SouthWest | $31.45 | $35.86 | $35.51 | $ ......

Words: 2299 - Pages: 10

Southwest Case Analysis

...Southwest Case Southwest airline is one of the major U.S. low-cost airlines in the United States. It was founded in 1966 from an idea of Rolling King a San Antonio entrepreneur who owned small commuter air service. The original plan was fairly simple attract passenger by offering convenient schedules, getting on time to their destination while having a good experience, all these while trying to charge the most competitive prices. Over the course of the years Southwest had to fight really hard in order to establish itself in the market because of fierce competition. In order to compete with other big airline, Southwest introduced important and revolutionary concept that have deeply affected the airlines world until now a days. Just to mention a few: taking cue from its hub at Dallas Love Field they started the so called “Love campaign” (Southwest’s airplanes were Love Birds, it’s drinks Love potion etc) this set the tone for Southwest’s approach to its customers to make flying with Southwest an enjoyable and fun experience. The company decided strategically to move from big, expensive Intercontinental Airports to smaller and closer to downtown airports. They also reduced to 10 minutes the turnaround time (the time spent refueling, off-loading passengers and bags and cleaning up the airplane in order to be ready for the next flight). Southwest was also the first to differentiate among its consumers. They offered generally low fares but in certain time and on certain days......

Words: 2987 - Pages: 12

Southwest Case Study

...Case Study - Southwest Airlines: Price-Value Equation Module 7 Case Study Roderick McPeak Embry Riddle Aeronautical University Southwest Airlines has been a model of admiration for the airline industry and businesses from around the world combined. Southwest Airlines is a rag to riches story that has had to fight for everything it has become. Before Southwest was able to take on its first passengers, they had to fight competitors in the court system for nearly three and a half years.  Southwest did not make its maiden voyage until 1971 – from a napkin to the airways with their runway in the Court system. When Texas Aeronautics Commission authorized Southwest to fly, their competitors grounded them within the Court system with continuous litigation for three and a half years. The litigation went as high as the Supreme Court. Finally, on June 18, 1971, Rollin King and Herb Kelleher started an airline service with one simple notion: "If you get your passengers to their destinations when they want to get there, on time, at the lowest possible fares, and make darn sure they have a good time doing it, people will fly your airline." They were right about that. Southwest Airline is now a major airline, in fact, the fourth largest airliner in the United States.  1) What benefits do airline customers seek when they buy air travel tickets? They have always had the lowest price in any market they serve. Because of the cost structure that was developed, Southwest did the......

Words: 814 - Pages: 4

Southwest Airlines Case

...Southwest Airlines in 2010 (pages 401-436) Gamble, J. E., Thompson, A. A., Jr., and Peteraf, M. A. (2013). Essentials of strategic management: The quest for competitive advantage (3rd ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill/Irwin. DISCUSSION QUESTIONS 1. What are the key policies, operating practices, and core values underlying Southwest’s efforts to implement its low-cost/no frills strategy? In order for Southwest Airlines to implement its low-cost/no frills strategy, they charge the lowest price possible to make air travel affordable to a wide segment. The lowest fares were usually nonrefundable but could be applied to future travel on Southwest Airlines, while rival airlines charged a change free of $100 to $175. Southwest Airlines also implemented the “Bags Fly Free” policy. Other airlines were charging up to $120 round trip to check bags due to the increase in jet fuel costs, but Southwest chose to let fliers check bags for free, which resulted in a company-record load factor. Southwest also uses dynamic pricing to charge more during peak travel periods. Southwest was able to experience revenue gains from increased ticket sales and passenger traffic. Southwest does not use the hub-and-spoke route systems of rival airlines and instead uses point-to-point scheduling. This allows Southwest to minimize the time aircraft is at the gate to 25 minutes. Southwest’s point-to-point route system minimized connections, delays, and total trip time. Southwest also has no......

Words: 1165 - Pages: 5

Southwest Case Study

...Southwest Case Study 1. What are some of the ways in which Southwest is different than other commercialairlines? There are many elements that contribute to Southwest Airlines' success in the airline industry. These elements include service, operations, cost control, marketing, and the corporate culture. Southwest made flying fun for employees and customers by making everyone feel like they are part of one big family. Management encouraged good relations between employees and passengers that resulted in high employee job satisfaction and low turnover. From an operational perspective, Southwest Airlines distinguished themselves from other airlines by incorporating cost saving programs such as the airline doing its own ticketing and not going through a travel agent. Southwest flew passengers nonstop to their destinations and did not promote connecting services. Southwest focused on flying passengers into uncongested airports and did not transfer baggage to other airlines. Only drinks and snacks were served on board. Southwest Airlines only flew newer Boeing 737 jets, which required less maintenance, and hence reduced the time needed to "turn" an aircraft around from an industry average of 55 minutes to 15 minutes or less. Southwest Airlines emphasized cost control and all employees worked together to minimize costs. Pilots developed new procedures regarding takeoffs and landings and fuel was purchased from vendors with the lowest prices. Marketing was an important element to...

Words: 2956 - Pages: 12

Southwest Case

...times for airplanes. Additionally, Southwest prides itself on delivering positively outrageous customer service (O’Reilly & Pfeffer, 1995). In fact, if Southwest were asked the question, “what business are we in” its most likely response would be, “we are in the business of providing excellent customer service.” For example, Southwest capitalizes the word “Customer” in all of its corporate communications in order to show how important their customers are (O’Reilly & Pfeffer, 1995). Another example is a Southwest employee offered to take care of a customer’s dog when the customer found out he could no longer take him on the airplane. The customer agreed, and the Southwest employee took care of the dog for two weeks so the customer could enjoy his vacation (O’Reilly & Pfeffer, 1995). These are just a few examples that show the importance that Southwest places on providing high levels of customer satisfaction. 1. Southwest’s Success Southwest has been successful for so long for a variety of reasons. One is the strategy that Southwest has is very effective because it has been able to provide value to customers in ways that other airlines have not been able to easily match (Cummings & Worley, 2015). Secondly, Southwest continues to be successful because they meet most of the criteria for an effective change process. Southwest has breadth, simplicity, unity, empowerment, and speed. Having these characteristics allows Southwest to change themselves......

Words: 1088 - Pages: 5

Southwest Airlines Case Study

...Southwest Airlines Calsouthern University Introduction “There is only one boss. The customer. And he can fire everybody in the company from the chairman on down, simply by spending his money somewhere else (Sam Walton, 2015).” Millions of people fly everyday. Southwest airlines provide low-fare travel among 58 cities in the United States. Although the airline industry suffered greatly in the aftermath of September 11, Southwest was able to continue to hold strong. Southwest airline continues to maintain steady sales as much of the industry was affected by changes in laws/regulations and competition entering the market. In the following report there is a brief introduction to Southwest Airlines and their strategy and then what, if anything, they need to do or not do to remain at the top and competitive in the airline industry. The Problem The major problem of the company is whether they can continue growing and at the same time keep offering the same services to their clients. To continue growing, Southwest Airlines needs to analyze the external environment in order to ensure their success.  The solutions that will be presented for Southwest airlines have to attack two main issues: 1. How will they be able to keep their “Southwest airlines LUV” 2. How to keep their expansion and not affect the image of the airline. Southwest Airlines has a list of infinite options, many will hinder their image from the inside out (employees to costumers) while providing a set of......

Words: 723 - Pages: 3

Southwest Case

...(PROGRMA ACREDITADO 2011 - 2015) | | Casos en Gestión Financiera Southwest Airlines Profesor: Juan Gallegos Mardones Autores: Camila Apablaza Juan Gabriel Castillo Héctor Garrido Esteban Soto 1 de Septiembre de 2012 Desarrollo de preguntas caso: Southwest Airlines 1. Analice el mercado de las aerolíneas en el que entra a competir Southwest (competidores, consumidores, proveedores, sustitutos, intensidad de la competencia, entorno de los negocios en general, reglas del juego, etc.) Al momento de la constitución de Southwest los competidores Braniff y Texas International Airlines sostenían que no había una demanda suficiente para la existencia de tres líneas aéreas en el mercado interestatal de Texas, luego de un año y medio de operación de la compañía ambos competidores iniciaron una guerra de precios, la cual produjo que Southwest redujera en un 50% el valor del billete en la ruta Dallas-Houston. Cabe mencionar que en el año 1992 Southwest fue la única línea aérea que fu rentable en los Estados Unidos y que en Abril de 1993, Southwest era la séptima aerolínea en importancia, en relación al número de pasajeros. Además sus competidores Braniff y Texas International Airlines ya habían desaparecido en estos años. La aerolínea desde sus inicios a conservado una estrategia de vuelos de corto recorrido, alta frecuencia y de bajo costo, debido a la baja duración media de los vuelos de Southwest (65 minutos), esta veía como uno de sus principales......

Words: 3076 - Pages: 13

Season 2 Episode 11 The Burrito | Tagebuch einer Nymphomanin | Infinix Infinix Charger - White -33% KSh 500 KSh 750 (1) GENUINE Buy now